Let's Make Robots!

RS232 Communication with MCU

So I am making my own CNC - PCB Miller. It is communicating with the computer using RS232 (UART), but in my testing, I find that I don't always get the correct characters, even at 1200baud. Does anyone have a method to suggest for error-checking an incoming data string over serial? I was thinking of doing something like this:

CPU sends data to MCU 4 times.

MCU checks to make sure the data is repeated exactly 4 times.

--If yes->send "OK" 4 times

--If no->send "NOT OK" 4 times

If CPU receives OK, queue up the next data to send

If CPU receives NOT OK, resend the previous data.


Since it's milling, I don't think I'll need it to go too quickly, 1200baud hopefully is fast enough.

Any suggestions on this method or a completely different proven method? I need it to be 100% correct data.


Thanks in advanced for your advice. 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hi Mitch, most of the industrial data checking routines are much less intensive than your proposed idea. A basic parity check for example is simply a binary value describing whether the last data string had an even or odd number of 1's, which means that a correct transmission will always get through, but incorrect transmissions will only be detected half of the time. Another method is to use hash sum checks, but they're a bit cumbersome and are normally used for error checking vs. larger data blocks.

I'd try your idea out, and if it's a little slow you can decrease the number of code repetitions. Have you added some basic analog filters to your data lines? You can really clean up the signal with a few caps and a balun or two.